New Jersey’s Hidden Gems: 7 Underrated Towns You Need to Explore

New Jersey. The Garden State. Often associated with bustling cities, crowded beaches, and the iconic Jersey Shore, it’s easy to overlook the charming, lesser-known towns that dot its landscape. Beyond the familiar, lies a treasure trove of history, culture, and natural beauty waiting to be discovered. If you’re looking for an escape from the ordinary and a taste of authentic New Jersey, then pack your bags and prepare to explore these 7 underrated towns. They offer unique experiences, rich histories, and a glimpse into the soul of the state that you won’t find anywhere else.

1. Frenchtown: A River Town With Artistic Flair

Nestled along the scenic Delaware River, Frenchtown is a captivating blend of small-town charm and artistic energy. This historic village, established in the late 1700s, boasts a vibrant Main Street lined with independently owned boutiques, art galleries, and antique shops. The town’s history as a mill town is evident in its beautifully preserved architecture, and its connection to the river is still very much alive.

• Why it’s Underrated: Frenchtown often gets overshadowed by more popular river towns, allowing it to retain a more authentic and laid-back atmosphere. Its artistic community thrives, making it a haven for those seeking unique and handcrafted goods.
• What to Do:
  • Explore Main Street: Browse the eclectic shops, art galleries, and antique stores. You’ll find everything from handcrafted jewelry to vintage clothing.
  • Walk or Bike the Delaware & Raritan Canal Path: The scenic path offers stunning views of the river and surrounding nature. Rent a bike or simply enjoy a leisurely stroll.
  • Attend a Festival or Event: Frenchtown hosts numerous festivals and events throughout the year, including the RiverFest, Bastille Day celebration, and various art walks. Check local listings for schedules.
  • Dine at a Local Restaurant: Sample farm-to-table cuisine at one of the many excellent restaurants in town. From cozy cafes to upscale dining, there’s something for everyone.
  • Visit the ArtYard: This contemporary art center hosts exhibitions, performances, and workshops.
• Where to Stay: Consider a stay at the charming Widow McCrea House, a historic bed and breakfast, or one of the quaint inns in the area.

2. Lambertville: Antiques and River Views

Just across the Delaware River from New Hope, Pennsylvania, lies Lambertville, another gem with a rich history and a thriving arts scene. Known as the “Antiques Capital of New Jersey,” this town is a haven for collectors and history buffs alike. Its picturesque streets, lined with Victorian-era buildings, create a charming backdrop for exploration.

• Why it’s Underrated: While its neighbor New Hope often draws the crowds, Lambertville offers a more relaxed and authentic experience. Its focus on antiques and local craftsmanship gives it a unique character.
• What to Do:
  • Go Antiquing: Explore the many antique shops and markets that line Bridge Street. You’re sure to find unique treasures and hidden gems.
  • Stroll Along the Delaware River: Enjoy scenic views and relax by the water. The river is perfect for a leisurely walk or a picnic.
  • Visit the Lambertville Historical Society: Learn about the town’s rich history and its role in the region.
  • Attend a Performance at the Music Mountain Theatre: Enjoy a live musical performance in this historic theater.
  • Dine at a Local Restaurant: Lambertville boasts a diverse culinary scene, from casual cafes to upscale dining establishments.
• Where to Stay: The Lambertville Station Inn offers a luxurious experience with river views, or choose one of the charming bed and breakfasts in town.

3. Cape May Point: A Coastal Escape

While Cape May City is a popular destination, its quieter neighbor, Cape May Point, offers a more tranquil and nature-focused experience. This small town, located at the southernmost tip of New Jersey, is a haven for birdwatchers and nature lovers. Its serene beaches, historic lighthouse, and wildlife refuge make it a unique coastal escape.

• Why it’s Underrated: Cape May Point provides a more laid-back and less crowded alternative to the bustling Cape May City. It offers a unique opportunity to connect with nature and escape the hustle and bustle.
• What to Do:
  • Visit the Cape May Lighthouse: Climb to the top for stunning panoramic views of the coastline. The lighthouse is a historic landmark and a must-see attraction. Cape May Lighthouse
  • Explore the Cape May Point State Park: Enjoy birdwatching, hiking, and picnicking in this beautiful natural area. The park is a major stopover point for migrating birds.
  • Relax on the Beaches: Enjoy the quieter, more secluded beaches of Cape May Point. Perfect for sunbathing, swimming, or simply relaxing by the water.
  • Visit the World War II Lookout Tower: Learn about the area’s role in World War II.
  • Enjoy Sunset Views: The sunsets over the Delaware Bay are breathtaking.
• Where to Stay: Choose from a variety of charming bed and breakfasts or vacation rentals in the area.

4. Clinton: Historic Mill Town Charm

Nestled along the Raritan River, Clinton is a historic mill town with a picturesque setting and a rich history. The town is known for its iconic Red Mill, a beautifully preserved gristmill that dates back to the early 1800s. Clinton’s charming Main Street, lined with historic buildings and unique shops, makes it a delightful place to explore.

• Why it’s Underrated: Clinton offers a more understated and authentic experience compared to other tourist destinations in New Jersey. Its focus on history and natural beauty makes it a hidden gem.
• What to Do:
  • Visit the Red Mill Museum: Explore the historic gristmill and learn about its role in the town’s history. Red Mill Museum
  • Walk Across the Bridge: The bridge over the Raritan River offers stunning views of the Red Mill and the town.
  • Explore Main Street: Browse the unique shops, art galleries, and antique stores. You’ll find a variety of treasures and handcrafted goods.
  • Enjoy the Outdoors: Take a walk or bike ride along the Raritan River.
  • Dine at a Local Restaurant: Experience the local cuisine at one of the many restaurants in town.
• Where to Stay: Consider a stay at one of the charming bed and breakfasts or inns in the area.

5. Millburn: A Suburban Gem with a Cultural Heart

Located in Essex County, Millburn is a sophisticated suburban town with a vibrant cultural scene. Known for its highly-regarded Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn offers a blend of small-town charm and big-city amenities. Its tree-lined streets, upscale boutiques, and excellent restaurants make it a desirable place to visit.

• Why it’s Underrated: Millburn often gets overlooked in favor of larger cities, but its unique combination of culture and charm makes it a worthy destination.
• What to Do:
  • Attend a Performance at the Paper Mill Playhouse: Enjoy a Broadway-caliber show at this renowned theater. Paper Mill Playhouse
  • Explore Downtown Millburn: Browse the upscale boutiques and specialty shops. You’ll find a variety of unique and fashionable items.
  • Dine at a Local Restaurant: Millburn boasts a diverse culinary scene, from casual cafes to fine dining establishments.
  • Visit Taylor Park: Enjoy a stroll through the park and admire the beautiful scenery.
  • Take a Class at the Millburn-Short Hills Art Center: Explore your creative side and take a class in painting, ceramics, or other art forms.
• Where to Stay: Choose from a variety of hotels and inns in the area, or opt for a charming bed and breakfast.

6. Collingswood: A Foodie Paradise

Located in Camden County, Collingswood is a vibrant town known for its thriving culinary scene and its commitment to the arts. The town’s Haddon Avenue is lined with award-winning restaurants, unique shops, and art galleries. Collingswood’s welcoming atmosphere and community spirit make it a delightful place to visit.

• Why it’s Underrated: While it’s gaining recognition, Collingswood often flies under the radar compared to other foodie destinations in the state. Its focus on local and artisanal food makes it a unique culinary haven.
• What to Do:
  • Explore Haddon Avenue: Browse the unique shops, art galleries, and restaurants.
  • Dine at an Award-Winning Restaurant: Sample the diverse culinary offerings of Collingswood’s many acclaimed restaurants.
  • Visit the Collingswood Farmers Market: Enjoy fresh, local produce and artisanal goods at this popular market. Collingswood Farmers Market
  • Attend a Local Event: Collingswood hosts numerous festivals and events throughout the year.
  • Enjoy a Performance at the Scottish Rite Auditorium: Experience a variety of live performances in this historic venue.
• Where to Stay: Choose from a variety of hotels and bed and breakfasts in the surrounding area.

7. Stockton: A Quaint River Village

Located along the Delaware River, Stockton is a small, charming village that exudes tranquility and history. Its historic buildings, scenic river views, and laid-back atmosphere make it a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. The town’s connection to the river is evident in its historic architecture and relaxed pace.

• Why it’s Underrated: Stockton often gets overlooked in favor of its larger neighbors, allowing it to retain a more secluded and peaceful atmosphere. Its focus on natural beauty and history makes it a hidden treasure.
• What to Do:
  • Walk or Bike the Delaware & Raritan Canal Path: Enjoy the scenic views of the river and surrounding nature.
  • Visit the Prallsville Mills: Explore this historic mill complex and learn about its role in the town’s history. Prallsville Mills
  • Explore the Town: Wander through the charming streets and admire the historic architecture.
  • Enjoy a Meal by the River: Dine at one of the local restaurants with stunning views of the Delaware River.
  • Go Kayaking or Canoeing: Rent a kayak or canoe and explore the Delaware River.
• Where to Stay: Consider a stay at one of the quaint bed and breakfasts or inns in the area.

Conclusion

New Jersey is more than just the Jersey Shore and bustling cities. These 7 underrated towns offer a glimpse into the diverse and captivating heart of the Garden State. From historic mill towns to coastal escapes, each location boasts unique experiences and a charm that you won’t find anywhere else. So, venture off the beaten path, explore these hidden gems, and discover the authentic beauty of New Jersey. You might just find that the best discoveries are the ones you least expect. Happy travels!